Three Sacramento County Superior Court Rulings on California High-Speed Rail – Bond Validation Lawsuit and Prop 1A Lawsuit – November 25, 2013

Print Friendly

California High-Speed Rail Court Decisions

November 25, 2013 California High Speed Rail Authority Bond Validation Lawsuit Ruling (original source http://www.saccourt.ca.gov/general/media/docs/tos-v-ca-high-speed-rail-authority-ruling-112513.pdf)

HIGH-SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY and HIGH-SPEED PASSENGER TRAIN FINANCE COMMITTEE, for the STATE OF CALIFORNIA, Plaintiffs, v. ALL PERSONS INTERESTED IN THE MATTER OF THE VALIDITY OF THE AUTHORIZATION AND ISSUANCE OF GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS TO BE ISSUED PURSUANT TO THE SAFE, RELIABLE HIGH-SPEED PASSENGER TRAIN BOND ACT FOR
THE 21ST CENTURY AND CERTAIN PROCEEDING AND MATTER RELATED THERETO.

  • It was NOT proven to be “necessary and desirable” to authorize bond sales on 3/18/13 for California High-Speed Rail.
  • I’m referenced on pages 7-8 & page 18 (footnote 30).

August 16, 2013 Tos Fukuda Kings County v California High-Speed Rail Prop 1A Part 1 Ruling (original source http://www.saccourt.ca.gov/general/media/docs/tos-v-ca-high-speed-rail-authority-ruling.pdf)

JOHN TOS, AARON FUKUDA, COUNTY OF KINGS, Plaintiffs and Petitioners, v. CALIFORNIA HIGH SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY, et al., Defendants and Respondents.

  • California High-Speed Rail doesn’t need to rescind its Tutor-Perini contract for first segment construction (Merced to Fresno).
  • The 2012 appropriation of funds to California High-Speed Rail from Senate Bill 1029 is not invalidated.

November 25, 2013 Tos Fukuda Kings County v California High-Speed Rail Prop 1A Part 2 Ruling (original source http://www.saccourt.ca.gov/general/media/docs/tos-v-ca-high-speed-rail-authority-ruling2-112513.pdf)

JOHN TOS, AARON FUKUDA, COUNTY OF KINGS, Plaintiffs and Petitioners, v. CALIFORNIA HIGH SPEED RAIL AUTHORITY, et al., Defendants and Respondents.

  • California High-Speed Rail Authority has to rescind its approval of its non-compliant November 3, 2011 funding plan.

News Media Coverage

Judge Blocks Sale of California High-Speed Rail Bonds – Associated Press (in Sacramento Bee) – November 25, 2013

California High-Speed Rail Funding Overturned by Judge – FOX 11 (Los Angeles) – November 25, 2013

Judge Blocks Use of State Bond Money for California Bullet TrainLos Angeles Times – November 25, 2013

California High-Speed Rail Plans Stopped in TracksSan Francisco Chronicle – November 26, 2013

California’s High-Speed Rail Imperiled by Court RulingsSan Jose Mercury-News – November 25, 2013

Sacramento Judge Sides with Kings County Plaintiffs, Puts California High-Speed Rail Plan on the RopesHanford Sentinel – November 25, 2013

California High-Speed Rail Bond Sale Rejected by Judge – www.bloomberg.com – November 25, 2013

Judge Grants Partial Victory to Foes of California Bullet Train – KQED – November 25, 2013

California Bond Sale for High-Speed Rail Project Blocked by Judge – Reuters – November 26, 2013

Locals Participated in High-Speed Rail Court Case – Bakersfield Californian – November 26, 2013

Judge Blocks Sale of California High-Speed Rail Bonds – Capitol Public Radio – November 25, 2013

California High Speed Rail Bond Sales Halted and Funding Plan Invalidatedwww.nextcity.org – November 26, 2013

Judge Strikes Down High Speed Rail Bond, Causing More DelaysSilicon Valley Business Journal – November 26, 2013

Court Instructs California High-Speed Rail to Redo Funding Plan; Refuses to Validate State Bonds – www.Examiner.com – November 26, 2013

Judge Deals Setback to California High-Speed Rail ProjectWall Street Journal – November 26, 2013

Applying a Brake to High-Speed PlansThe Economist – November 26, 2013

California Judge Cuts Off State Funding for High-Speed Train Venture – FOX News Channel – November 26, 2013

Judge’s Rulings Favor Opponents of Rail Project – www.agalert.com – November 26, 2013

LaMalfa: High-Speed Rail ‘Dead in the Water’Redding Record-Searchlight – November 26, 2013

California Bullet Train Might Be Breathing Its LastMother Jones – November 25, 2013

Will High-Speed Rail Keep Rolling Ahead? – columnist Dan Walters (video) – Sacramento Bee – November 26, 2013

Hurdle for High-Speed Rail: Where is the Money? – Associated Press (in Sacramento Bee) – November 26, 2013

Hurdle For California High-Speed Rail: Where Is The Money? – KPIX Channel 5 (San Francisco), video – November 26, 2013

Judge Issues Setback to California’s High-Speed Rail Plan – KQED Forum, radio interview – November 27, 2013

  • Dan Richard, chairman, California High-Speed Rail Authority
  • Juliet Williams, political reporter for the Associated Press
  • Quentin Kopp, former chairman of California State Senate transportation committee

Bullet Train Snag Could Affect Transbay Terminal – columnists Matier & Ross (in San Francisco Chronicle) – November 27, 2013

High-Speed Rail Ruling Threatens To Derail Future Of Caltrain – KPIX Channel 5 (San Francisco), video – November 27, 2013

California State Senator Mark DeSaulnier Talks About The Fate Of High-Speed Rail – KPIX Channel 5 (San Francisco), video – December 1, 2013

Editorials

Bullet-Train Fiasco: Gov. Brown, Heed the JudgeUT San Diego – November 25, 2013

Time to End the California High-Speed Rail Fraud – Bay Area News Group (Contra Costa Times, Oakand Tribune, etc.) – November 26, 2013

Hit the Brakes on California’s High-Speed Rail FraudLos Angeles Daily News – November 26, 2013

Pump the Brakes on Bullet TrainRiverside Press-Enterprise – November 26, 2013

Judge Detours Plans for Bullet TrainOrange County Register – November 26, 2013

Bullet Train Must Deliver on Its Pledge to VotersVentura County Star – November 26, 2013

High-Speed Rail Proceeds in Fits and StartsSacramento Bee – November 27, 2013

Bumps in the Path of High-Speed RailSan Francisco Chronicle – December 1, 2013

Commentary

California Judge Sends High-Speed Rail Plan Careening Backward Into the Station – Reason Foundation – November 25, 2013

Rube Goldberg Legal System Derails California Bullet Train – The American Interest – November 26, 2013

End Game on Bullet Train: No $, No Project – and No Prospects for $ – CalWatchdog – November 26, 2013

Court Rules Against Bullet Train Authority – Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association (in www.foxandhoundsdaily.com) – November 26, 2013

Obama’s Bullet Train Dream Just Derailed in California – American Enterprise Institute – November 26, 2013

2 comments

  1. […] parties. They want the court to grant relief to allow the project to continue, even though a Sacramento County Superior Court judge decided in 2013 that the California High-Speed Rail Authority failed to comply with the law established by […]

  2. […] parties. They want the court to grant relief to allow the project to continue, even though a Sacramento County Superior Court judge decided in 2013 that the California High-Speed Rail Authority failed to comply with the law established by […]