Tag Archive for San Diego County Treasurer

Michigan Reporter Joel Thurtell Provides Background on How Michigan Banned Capital Appreciation Bonds

UPDATE: Joel Thurtell has now posted (on his web site Joel on the Road) the “big graphic” – a table associated with his 1993 exposé of Michigan school districts selling Capital Appreciation Bonds (CABs). The table lists the Michigan school districts that sold Capital Appreciation Bonds, the amount of bonds sold, the amount of interest to be paid to investors, the length of time from sale to maturity, and the interest as a percentage of the principal (the amount borrowed).

To give readers an understandable comparison, the table also provides the numbers for a conventional mortgage at 7% for various time periods. (Try it at 4% today.)

These amounts and percentages are peanuts compared to what California K-12 and community college districts are selling as Capital Appreciation Bonds. Notice the highest percentages of interest to principal in Michigan school districts were 575% and 406%. In California, the Poway Unified School District’s 2011 bond sales were at 935%.

The next step in the process to ban California educational districts from selling Capital Appreciation Bonds is for someone to re-create this chart for California and circulate it widely.

Joel Thurtell (web site Joel on the Road) is the now-retired Detroit Free Press reporter whose intensively-researched 1993 articles about Michigan school districts borrowing money by selling Capital Appreciation Bonds were the catalyst for a 1994 Michigan ban on Capital Appreciation Bonds. Now he is working to make sure California citizens aren’t victimized by the same scam.

Through his blog, Joel Thurtell was the first reporter to publicly expose how California’s K-12 school districts and community college districts have been selling Capital Appreciation Bonds as a way to borrow money for school construction. His attention to this obscure but extremely costly and disingenuous method of borrowing money has been acknowledged by various news stories throughout California (Community College Districts’ Bonds Inflate Taxpayers’ Repayments– Sacramento Bee – August 22, 2012; High Cost of School Bond Shocks Poway – San Diego Union-Tribune – August 17, 2012; Kudos to Michigan Journalist on the Poway Bond Story– Voice of San Diego – August 8, 2012; Joel Thurtell Shames Poway, CA Financing– Daily Markets – August 10, 2012; School Bonds Could Trigger Fiscal Shock – Financial Times via CNBC – August 9, 2012)

The Voice of San Diego web newspaper finally managed to grab the attention of the state’s political leaders and news media with an article on August 8, 2012: Where Borrowing $105 Million Will Cost $1 Billion: Poway Schools – Voice of San Diego – August 6, 2012. I continue to believe that it was the Voice of San Diego’s simple pie chart of the Poway Unified School District’s bond repayments (designed by Keegan Kyle) that allowed this story to fly – give Mr. Kyle a Pulitzer.

I found out about Mr. Thurtell’s crusade to alert Californians to the Capital Appreciation Bond racket when his 1993 Detroit Free Press articles were referenced by Mt. Diablo Unified School District 2010 Measure C Citizens Bond Oversight Committee member Alicia Minyen at the California League of Bond Oversight Committees annual conference on May 9. I wrote about the presentation about Capital Appreciation Bonds at this conference in a couple of mid-May blog posts, which have received a consistent trickle of attention since then.

Now, with San Diego County Treasurer Dan McAllister promoting an outline of possible legislation to restrict the sale of Capital Appreciation Bonds in California, Joel Thurtell has posted Public Act 278, the 1994 law that banned Michigan school districts from selling Capital Appreciation Bonds. He indicates that the relevant sections are 380.1352a (Borrowing money and issuing bonds); 380.1351b (Appreciation or sale at discount); and 380.1352 (Borrowing or issuing bonds; contract for legal representation).

Joel Thurtell has also posted the text of most of his 1993 Detroit Free Press articles about Capital Appreciation Bond sales by Michigan school districts, although as of August 26, 2012 he was still preparing additional unpublished text from the first article, dated April 5, 1993, and related charts published in the newspaper.

This Michigan law banning the sale of Capital Appreciation Bonds was enacted shortly before major newspapers and most state legislative web sites began posting content electronically on the web. (For example, the Michigan and California legislative web sites post bills starting with the 1995 sessions.) Try to research any state or local public policy activity before 1995, and everything is a lot more difficult! Thank you to Joel Thurtell for taking the time to provide public access to how the people of Michigan handled the Capital Appreciation Bond sales in their school districts in the early 1990s.

San Diego County Treasurer Drafts Outline of Legislative Proposal to Restrict and Expose How California School Districts Sell Capital Appreciation Bonds


Now posted on the County of San Diego Treasurer’s web site:

Information about San Diego County Treasurer Dan McAllister’s August 21, 2012 press conference and presentation materials about Capital Appreciation Bonds.

A YouTube video of San Diego County Treasurer Dan McAllister‘s August 21, 2012 press conference: SD County Treasurer Dan McAllister Calls for School Bond Reform

UPDATE 2: The San Diego Union-Tribune reports on Senator Mark Wyland‘s Senate Bill 1205, which was amended on March 28, 2012 to impose restrictions on the sale of Capital Appreciation Bonds by K-12 school and community college districts. Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association official David Wolfe, who also serves on the Board of Directors of the California League of Bond Oversight Committees, is quoted in support of the bill. Senate Bill 1205 never had a hearing and never had a legislative analysis.

Lawmaker Sought to Stop Controversial Bond Financing – San Diego Union-Tribune – August 23, 2012

A little more than three months after the California League of Bond Oversight Committees (CalBOC) annual conference brought my attention to school districts and community college districts selling Capital Improvement Bonds (CABs) to borrow money for school construction, a prominent public official has proposed legislation to increase public awareness of the practice and rein it in.

Yesterday (August 21, 2012), San Diego County Treasurer Dan McAllister held a press conference to announce the outline of a legislative proposal to deal with Capital Appreciation Bonds. At the time of this writing, his office inexplicably does not have any information about the press conference or the proposal on its County of San Diego Treasurer web site, but the San Diego Union-Tribune posted his letter and proposal on its own web site. See them here:

Outline of the Proposed Capital Appreciation Bond Reform from the San Diego County Treasurer

Letter from the San Diego County Treasurer Explaining the Need for Capital Appreciation Bond Reform

As I wrote in my August 11, 2012 blog post (News Media Beginning to Pick Up on Story about California School Districts Selling Insidious “Capital Appreciation Bonds” – Dayton Public Policy Institute an Early Informant to California Taxpayers), the attraction of Capital Appreciation Bonds for California school districts and community college districts has been referenced in various specialty publications, including the CalBOC Newsletter, my own Dayton Public Policy Institute blog posts on Capital Appreciation Bonds, and originally in Joel Thurtell’s blog www.JoelontheRoad.com.

It was a set of articles earlier this month in the Voice of San Diego about the Poway Unified School District sale of Capital Appreciation Bonds that really brought the story to mainstream public attention. People get motivated when they are the direct victims! For proof that the school district borrowed $105,000,150 by selling Capital Appreciation Bonds and will need to pay investors $981,562,329 by 2052, see page 12 of the Poway Unified School District’s Proposition C Bond Building Fund Annual Audit Report, January 31, 2012.

I hope the California Association of County Treasurers and Tax Collectors can align with the California League of Bond Oversight Committees (CalBOC) and various state and regional taxpayers organizations such as the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association to enact bipartisan legislation in 2012 to restrict or ban the sale of Capital Appreciation Bonds by school districts and community college districts. My statement about Capital Appreciation Bonds:

School board members don’t care how much these Capital Appreciation Bonds cost after 30 or 40 years. By the time property owners are assessed with the staggering tax burden, the elected board members will be out of office and probably dead. They won’t be accountable for the consequences, but they’ll still have their names on rusty plaques next to the front doors of deteriorating schools.

Latest News Media Coverage of CAB Reform

School Bond Reform Gaining Support – San Diego Union-Tribune – August 22, 2012

Tax Collector Blasts Poway Unified Bonds, Calls for Reform – North County Times – August 22, 2012

County Treasurer Calls for Widespread School Bonds Reform – Voice of San Diego – August 22, 2012

Poway Unified Residents Fume Over Expensive Bond: School District Officials Explain, Defend Decision Behind $1 Billion Debt – San Diego Union-Tribune – August 21, 2012

Poway Bond is a Billion-Dollar Box-Office Bomb – San Diego Union-Tribune (columnist Logan Jenkins) – August 21, 2012

County Treasurer Calls for Widespread School Bonds Reform – Voice of San Diego – August 21, 2012

A Creative Borrowing Boom: VOSD Radio – Voice of San Diego – August 20, 2012

Tonight: Big School Board Meeting in Poway – Voice of San Diego – August 20, 2012

High Cost of School Bond Shocks Poway Unified: Repayment Under Financing Plan Will Be 9 Times the Principal – San Diego Union-Tribune – August 17, 2012

‘Wow, If True Then That Is Financial Suicide’: Comments on School Bonds – Voice of San Diego – August 10, 2012

Find High-Interest School Bonds in Your District: A Five-Step Guide – Voice of San Diego – August 8, 2012

A Creative Borrowing Boom: Poway Not Alone in High-Interest Financing – Voice of San Diego – August 7, 2012

Where Borrowing $105 Million Will Cost $1 Billion: Poway Schools – Voice of San Diego – August 6, 2012